Welcome! Free Economy Shipping on Orders Over $75

Collection: Used Cookie Cutters

*Cutters are measured at their longest point.*

Ridged Circle Cookie Cutter with Handle (2 1/2")

Ridged Circle Cookie Cutter with Handle (2 1/2")

Regular price $0.75 USD

Regular price Sale price $0.75 USD
Unit price per
Santa Cookie Cutter with Handle (3 3/4")

Santa Cookie Cutter with Handle (3 3/4")

Regular price $0.75 USD

Regular price Sale price $0.75 USD
Unit price per
Moon with Handle Cookie Cutter (3 1/2")

Moon with Handle Cookie Cutter (3 1/2")

Regular price $0.75 USD

Regular price Sale price $0.75 USD
Unit price per
Thin Bell Cookie Cutter (2 3/4")

Thin Bell Cookie Cutter (2 3/4")

Regular price $0.75 USD

Regular price Sale price $0.75 USD
Unit price per
Jolly Roger Skull and Crossbones Cookie Cutter (3 1/2")

Jolly Roger Skull and Crossbones Cookie Cutter (3 1/2")

Regular price $1.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $1.00 USD
Unit price per
Circle Cookie Cutter Set with Tin

Circle Cookie Cutter Set with Tin

Regular price $5.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $5.00 USD
Unit price per
Small Snowman with Hat Cookie Cutter (3")

Small Snowman with Hat Cookie Cutter (3")

Regular price $1.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $1.00 USD
Unit price per
Waving Snowman Cookie Cutter (3 1/4")

Waving Snowman Cookie Cutter (3 1/4")

Regular price $1.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $1.00 USD
Unit price per
Twin Bells Cookie Cutter (3 3/4")

Twin Bells Cookie Cutter (3 3/4")

Regular price $1.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $1.00 USD
Unit price per
Christmas Light/Light Bulb/Leaf/Christmas Ornament Cookie Cutter (3")

Christmas Light/Light Bulb/Leaf/Christmas Ornament Cookie Cutter (3")

Regular price $1.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $1.00 USD
Unit price per
Fancy Christmas Ornament Cookie Cutter (3 1/2")

Fancy Christmas Ornament Cookie Cutter (3 1/2")

Regular price $1.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $1.00 USD
Unit price per
Holly Leaf Cookie Cutter (3 1/4")

Holly Leaf Cookie Cutter (3 1/4")

Regular price $1.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $1.00 USD
Unit price per
Large Bear Cookie Cutter (5 1/4")

Large Bear Cookie Cutter (5 1/4")

Regular price $2.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $2.00 USD
Unit price per
Large Turkey Side View Cookie Cutter (4 1/2")

Large Turkey Side View Cookie Cutter (4 1/2")

Regular price $2.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $2.00 USD
Unit price per
Squat Teapot Cookie Cutter (3 1/2")

Squat Teapot Cookie Cutter (3 1/2")

Regular price $1.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $1.00 USD
Unit price per
Coffee Pot/Tall Teapot Cookie Cutter (2 3/4")

Coffee Pot/Tall Teapot Cookie Cutter (2 3/4")

Regular price $1.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $1.00 USD
Unit price per
Fancy Teapot Cookie Cutter (3 3/4")

Fancy Teapot Cookie Cutter (3 3/4")

Regular price $1.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $1.00 USD
Unit price per
Leaping Reindeer Cookie Cutter (3 3/4")

Leaping Reindeer Cookie Cutter (3 3/4")

Regular price $1.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $1.00 USD
Unit price per
Small Snowman with Top Hat Cookie Cutter (3")

Small Snowman with Top Hat Cookie Cutter (3")

Regular price $1.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $1.00 USD
Unit price per
Mitten Cookie Cutter (3")

Mitten Cookie Cutter (3")

Regular price $1.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $1.00 USD
Unit price per